• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
Parry Field Lawyers
  • Home
  • About
    • News
    • Terms of Engagement
  • Our People
  • Services
    • Property
      • Residential
      • Construction
      • Subdivisions
      • Commercial
      • Leasing
    • Advisory
      • Employment
      • Sale & Purchases
      • Financing
      • Governance
      • Technology/IT
      • Capital Raising
    • Disputes
      • Employment
      • Court, Tribunals and Arbitrations
      • Estates & Wills
      • Divorce & Separation
      • Insurance
      • Family
      • Company & Shareholding
      • Debt Collection
      • Construction
    • Trusts & Asset Planning
      • Wills & Enduring Powers of Attorney
      • Estates
      • Succession Planning
    • Charities/For Purpose Organisations
      • Incorporated Societies: Information Hub
      • Charities: Information Hub
      • Faith Based Groups: Information Hub
      • Impact Investing: Information Hub
      • Hybrid Solutions: Charity/Business
      • Not for Profits
      • Churches
      • Sports Groups
      • Social Enterprises/Impact Companies
      • Community Groups
    • Immigration
      • Work Visas
      • Family Visas
      • Skilled Migrants
      • Business and Investment Visas
      • Potentially Prejudicial Information
      • Employer Assistance
      • Overseas Investment
  • Resources
    • Guides
      • Capital Raising Guide
      • Resources for the Incorporated Societies Act 2022
      • Doing Business In New Zealand
      • Start Ups Legal Toolkit
      • Buying & Selling Property
      • Charities In New Zealand
      • Social Enterprises in New Zealand Handbook
      • Family Trusts
      • Death & Estates
      • Churches Handbook
      • COVID-19 Legal Handbook
    • Articles
      • Heat of the moment resignations – do employees need to be given a chance to cool off?
      • The new Incorporated Societies Act 2022: When will the new Act affect my Society?
      • Racial Harassment in the Workplace
      • Built up annual leave – does an employee have to use it?
      • Resources for the Incorporated Societies Act 2022
      • When can a Trustee delegate their powers?
      • Buying your first home: Key issues (a practical guide from a first home buyer)
      • The new Incorporated Societies Act 2022: What it means for your Incorporated Society
      • The Addington Farm: A case study in setting up a Charity
      • The Bright-Line Test
      • Funds that advance charity: How do they work? 
      • What is a LIM?
      • Charity Founders’ Ongoing Relationship With The Charity They Start: Key points to know
    • Blog
    • Templates
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Terms and Conditions Including Software
      • Non-Disclosure Agreement – One Way
      • Non-Disclosure Agreement – Two Way
      • Independent Contractors Agreement
      • Shareholders’ Resolutions – Written resolution
      • Share Transfer
      • Incorporation – First Shareholder Resolutions
      • Incorporation – First Directors’ Resolutions
    • Videos
      • COVID-19 and Commercial Leases
      • Force Majeure” clauses in Contracts and COVID-19
      • Property sale and purchases and COVID-19
      • Seeds Podcast
  • Careers
  • Contact
    • Healthcheck
  • Pay Online
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

Preliminary Decisions in Employment Dismissals – Are they required?

Employment

It is well established in New Zealand’s employment law that there are certain things employers must do prior to justifiably dismissing an employee.  These things fall into two categories, having a justified reason and following a fair process.  It is not unusual to find cases where an employee’s dismissal is found by the Employment Relations Authority or Employment Court to be unjustified, not because there was no basis to take action against an employee but because the employer’s process was significantly flawed.

For example, in some cases, employers who haven’t sufficiently investigated allegations or given their employee a fair opportunity to explain their side of things, have been found to have breached proper process, which has ultimately resulted in the ERA determining that their dismissal of an employee was unjustified.

However, if an employer has carried out a fair process and ultimately reached a decision to dismiss, are they also required to tell their employee their preliminary decision and give them the chance to feed back on the same, prior to making a final decision?

While there is no obligation in the Employment Relations Act to do so, increasingly preliminary decisions are now seen as best practice, namely employers should provide a preliminary decision to their employees, including all details of any proposed disciplinary action, and allow their employees to give their feedback.

This helps ensure that the employee has had a full opportunity to comment on all relevant matters before a decision is finalised, which not only reduces risks to the employer (for example, they may have misunderstood something the employee said, which might change the employer’s decision) but also promotes good faith between the parties.  Further, it enables the employer to think through their decision and the basis for it, in advance of taking final action, which is then binding on them.

If a preliminary decision is given however, it must not indicate that the employer has already made up their mind, as that will not constitute a genuine opportunity for the employee to provide feedback, including potentially changing the employer’s decision.  In other words, it should convey that the decision is preliminary only and the employer will consider all feedback provided by the employee on it before deciding whether to proceed with the decision or not.  Further, the employer must fully and genuinely consider the employee’s feedback on the preliminary decision before either confirming that decision or advising of a changed decision (such as to only issue a final warning, rather than to dismiss the employee).

In summary, we recommend that, once an investigation (into say misconduct) has concluded and a preliminary decision has been reached:

  • this should initially be sent to an employee in the form of a preliminary decision letter, with the option given to either choose whether the employee’s feedback is provided in writing or in person.
  • a reasonable amount of time is given to the employee between the preliminary decision being provided and feedback being due (this will be fact dependent but usually no less than 24 hours).
  • sufficient time is taken to genuinely consider the feedback, once it is received, prior to making a final decision (again this will be fact specific).

If you require any assistance regarding starting a disciplinary process or advice in respect of making a preliminary decision, please do not hesitate to contact our employment team.

This article is not a substitute for legal advice and you should consult your lawyer about your specific situation. Please feel free to contact us at Parry Field Lawyers:

  • Mike Henderson-Rauter, Senior Solicitor – mikehenderson-rauter@parryfield.com
  • Hannah Carey, Senior Counsel – hannahcarey@parryfield.com
https://www.parryfield.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/IMG_20210219_190611-scaled.jpg 1707 2560 Kylie Shipley https://www.parryfield.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Parry-Field-Lawyers-Logo.png Kylie Shipley2022-07-14 14:33:252022-07-14 14:33:25Preliminary Decisions in Employment Dismissals – Are they required?

Related Lawyers

Mike Henderson-Rauter
Email Mike
03-348-8480
View Profile
Hannah Carey
Email Hannah
+6433488480
View Profile

Christchurch CBD

PHONE: +64 3 348 8480
FAX: +64 3 348 6305

PHYSICAL ADDRESS:
Level 1, 60 Cashel Street
Christchurch 8013, New Zealand

POSTAL ADDRESS:
PO Box 744
Christchurch, 8140, New Zealand

Christchurch

PHONE: +64 3 348 8480
FAX: +64 3 348 6305

PHYSICAL ADDRESS:
1 Rimu Street, Riccarton,
Christchurch 8041, New Zealand

POSTAL ADDRESS:
PO Box 8020, Riccarton,
Christchurch, 8440, New Zealand

Rolleston

PHONE: +64 3 348 8480
FAX: +64 3 348 6305

PHYSICAL ADDRESS:
Level 1, 80 Rolleston Drive,
Rolleston, 7614, New Zealand

POSTAL ADDRESS:
PO Box 8020, Riccarton,
Christchurch, 8440, New Zealand

Hokitika

PHONE: +64 3 755 8673
FAX: +64 3 755 8073

PHYSICAL ADDRESS:
26 Weld Street,
Hokitika 7810, New Zealand

POSTAL ADDRESS:
PO Box 44,
Hokitika 7842, New Zealand

Parry Field Charitable Foundation

Parry Field charitable members of NZ LAw, Global Cross Legal and SCLA

© Copyright – Parry Field Lawyers     |     Privacy Policy

Contractor vs Employee: The Grey ZoneIncorporated Societies vs Charitable Trusts
Scroll to top